We’ve all heard the term ‘close the gate’ the term given to the hips on the downswing as they turn through to a full finish.
Although I completely agree with this meaning, it’s important to understand that in the backswing the gate (the hips) have to open.
Many people don’t open/turn their hips enough in their takeaway and in turn their hands don’t move in the intended direction. We want the hands to not only move backwards, not only move upwards, but also move inwards. This can only happen when the pivot (body) functions properly.
It’s true that in the backswing we want the hands to lead the arms that lead the body, and then reverse the sequence on the way down. But it’s also important to understand that this sequence must happen sooner rather than later for the hands to do their job.
The 1 inch takeaway
For the hands to be able to move inside on the takeaway, the right hip must start moving out of the way to give the hands some room to move. If the hips are too static in the takeaway the hands generally tend to track along the toe line which is too straight. As mentioned the hands should move back, up and in.
If the hands move the arms, and the arms move the body – which includes the shoulders and hips. Try and practice a takeaway which involves the hands moving no more than an inch or so before you can start feeling some hip rotation. A great way to understand this chain reaction of movements is to start allowing the right knee to straighten as soon as you start moving your hands in the takeaway. this will facilitate the right hip moving upwards and allow the left hip to start moving downwards. This happens when the left leg bends and the right leg straightens in the backswing.
I’ve seen so many people get confused with the takeaway and backswing by trying to move one part of their body then the next then the next. Simply try and get everything functioning well right from the get go..
This is really what a one piece takeaway is – and it has been taught for a very long time. It’s a feeling that everything is connected during the takeaway and stays connected during the backswing.
The hands have to lead the way as they travel the furthest in the swing. Followed by the arms, which move the shoulders, which move the hips. The idea that there should be very little hip turn in the backswing has never made sense to me. This idea just confuses people. I want you to try and turn your hips. With your right leg straightening a little and your left leg flexing a little during the backswing your hips will easily turn a good 40/50 degrees. Your shoulders will turn around 90 degrees so there is your resistance. Don’t ever try and resist turning your hips that will get you in a whole lot of trouble.
The idea of opening the gate with your hips allows you to easily move your hands in the correct direction in the takeaway. What we want to do then is to allow the club to lag and load in your hands at the top of the swing and maintain that lag as your hands and arms move back down in front of your hips before you close the gate into your follow through.
Many good players suffer from this sequencing issue and inevitably get their arms and hands in a trapped position coming down into impact. This is where the hips have fired and turned through too soon leaving the hands and arms too far behind playing catch up. From this position the hands have to make a compensatory movement and will probably lead to a slightly flipped or bent left wrist position at impact instead of flat left wrist position at impact.
Drill
Practice mini backswings where your hands don’t come any higher than your hips. If you’ve rotated your hips (opened the gate) during your takeaway, your job then is to get your hands and arms back in front of your hips before you turn your hips through (close the gate).
A great exercise to build your awareness is to place an alignment rod or a piece of doweling through your belt loops when you swing. if your hips turn too soon coming down (closing the gate too quickly) your right arm will get caught against the rod. The idea is to get your right elbow back down in front of the rod before turning through and closing the gate. This way you’ll be in the best position to attack the ball and be able to achieve a flat left wrist and a bent right wrist through impact which is essential to good ball striking. This isn’t to say the hips don’t turn coming down they do, they are pulling the torso and arms down and through. It just means that your arms and hands should be traveling a lot faster that your hips to get back in front of them.
Have a question? I’d love to hear what you have to say. Please leave a comment below
James, a couple of comments. This is a pretty complicated article. Here’s a couple sentences that caught my attention:
In the 1 inch takeaway section: ‘If the hands move the arms, and the arms move the body – which includes the shoulders and hips.”
You know us hackers have perfected all sorts of bad habits including moving the arms and shoulders without moving the hips much at all. (The curse of the Jim McClean “X-Factor” fad) The hips are virtually independent of the torso – we are designed that way. As you state, “everything is connected during the backswing” i.e., it’s consciously allowing the shoulders-torso-hips to turn as a unit on the takeaway. But I think this insight has to mention that as the hips turn to the right, the inside of the right thigh is loaded.
In the “Drill” section you say: “It just means that your arms and hands should be traveling a lot faster that your hips to get back in front of them.” There was a fascinating Minolta Slow Motion Vision piece recently which asked the question, “during which phase of the forward swing are the hips moving the fastest?”
The answer: when the arms are halfway to the ball. Think about this. The forward swing is initiated from the ground up. The legs and hips lead the torso-shoulders-arms-hands to create a whipping motion. What the camera shows is the hips slow down from that point as the left leg straightens (applying leverage).
I should have saved that video so I could see where right elbow gets in front of the body and the arms accelerate/catch up. But I don’t believe we hackers have the problem of the hips turning too fast during the forward swing. The most prevalent problem is the arms and shoulders leading the forward swing i.e., an out of sequence forward swing.
I’ve been working on the forward swing sequence and will try your drill using my alignment rod to see if I’m getting my right elbow in front of my body at the right time. Physical fitness is a big part of being able to maintain the correct posture and execute the weight transfer and swing sequence.
Bob, agreed! There’s definitely a loading of the weight into the right leg during the back swing. But most people load too much weight into the back leg and then struggle to move the weight forward fast enough on the downswing. Take a look at this article, pretty interesting.. http://www.jamesparkergolf.com/foot-pressure-in-the-golf-swing/
Hi, great article. Couple of questions: what’s your main feel or muscle group that gets the right hip into the proper backswing pivot position. Also, do you see any relationship to the left knee and right elbow on the transition? Kinda like a rope connecting the two…the left slightly laterally pulls the right elbow down into the correct position? Thanks
Thanks Rodney. The right hip should move back behind you, closer to the target, and also upwards. This can only happen when the right leg straightens a little on the backswing. Try focusing on your tailbone moving closer to the target – here’s a great drill to practice https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vkjm_AVwiBM.
As for the left knee and right elbow – sure! it’s all connected. The left side pulls and the right side pushes. But make sure most of your attention is in your hands. It’s your hands that control the tool.
Thanks James, I have the tendency to drag the club back to long and over restrict my hips which seems to screw up my tempo and freedom to drop the club back inside on DS. This should help. When referencing the hands, are you wanting the left hand leading the control which enables the right elbow fold or visa versa?
Rodney, start allowing the right leg to straighten a little during your takeaway and make sure you feel like you are tilting your spine towards the target.
The right arm folding allows the left wrist to hinge. if you look at someone like Bubba Watson, he keeps his trail arm pretty straight during his takeaway and therefore doesn’t have much wrist cock.
[…] Bobby Eldridge Golf – Releasing the Golf Club in the DownswingSimple Tips for Correcting Your Golf SliceOpen the Gate | To a proper functioning pivot and swing sequence – James Parker Golf […]
Sorry James, but I am reading a lot of the same confusing jargon traditional golf instruction has been guilty of for decades. First you say you “want the hands to lead the arms that lead the body” in the takeaway. Next you talk about the takeaway as a connected “one piece” movement which implies everything moving together at the same time. Well which is it – a sequenced hands, arms, body movement or one piece? In the downswing you talk of the turning hips “pulling the torso and arms down and through” implying the arms are relatively passive. Yet you then say “the arms and hands should be traveling a lot faster than your hips”. From what source are the arms getting this extra speed? Are the arms (and shoulders) muscles being more active and supplying the extra arm speed? If so why don’t you mention this? I am not trying to be negative – it is just that golf instruction is always vague on these explanations – what is causing what to move and what is active and what is passive!.
Don, Thank you for taking the time to comment on my blog. I also say “The hands have to lead the way as they travel the furthest in the swing” If you don’t put any attention in your hands, what is going to steer the ship – so to speak?
I agree, this blog is a little confusing and I could have worded it better. I believe part of our job as teachers is to find out what we should be feeling and try and translate that. What I tried to do in this article was explain why many people ‘spin’ out with their hips too early in the downswing. In trying to do so I guess I went on a rant. It happens!
Since writing this article I’ve learned more about how the spine works in the swing, and the importance of ‘regaining flexion’ during the transition. If you can learn how to do that, this article will make a little more sense I think. Here’s the link https://www.jamesparkergolf.com/improve-your-timing-by-regaining-flexion/ it also includes a video. let me know what you think.
[…] This is what I tried to explain in this blog post a while back. […]